10 Movies From The 2010s That Divided Critics And Rotten Tomatoes Fans


Review aggregator website Rotten Tomatoes is a useful tool for moviegoers, with the site’s various reviewers giving each film and series a rotten or fresh score. With several decades of history, the website has helpfully rated thousands of movies.

But while Rotten Tomatoes has often been a key indicator of a movie’s quality, audiences don’t always agree with its ratings. In fact, over time, fans find themselves increasingly at odds with movie critics, including in the case of several popular movies from the 2010s.


Ghostbusters (2016)

Available on Amazon Prime Video

ghost hunters has always been a beloved franchise, which means its 2016 female-led reboot was destined to be controversial. Despite the film’s incredibly negative reception online, the reboot did pretty well with reviews on Rotten Tomatoes, earning a 73% approval rating. Audiences felt differently, however, with only 49% of viewers finding the film enjoyable, marking a 24 percentage point disparity between the two ratings.

However ghost hunters wasn’t the absolute disaster that many fans thought it would be, nor was it the success needed to bring the franchise back to life. As a result, many who had worried about the film’s quality felt validated in their concern, cementing audiences in a largely negative view of the reboot.

Justice League (2017)

Available on HBO Max

Justice League is the biggest crossover event yet in the DCEU, bringing together the franchise’s greatest heroes in one film. The film itself, however, was not a particular favorite with critics, especially on Rotten Tomatoes, where the film holds a dismal 39% approval rating, albeit weighted by a somewhat generous 68% score. with the public, creating a gap of 29 points.

There’s nothing about Justice League it’s not complicated. Wrapped up in behind-the-scenes drama, it’s a miracle the movie ever hit theaters in the first place. However, much of the crossover event’s shortcomings stem from its mid-production director swap, with Joss Whedon replacing Zach Snyder, resulting in a hybrid film that pleased few critics and led to fans campaigning. for the infamous “Snyder Cut” for years.

Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Men Tell Nothing (2017)

Available on Disney+

Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Men Tell No Tales is the fifth film of the Pirates of the Caribbean franchise, which features the return of Johnny Depp’s greatest character of all time, Captain Jack Sparrow. Rotten Tomatoes took a particular dislike to the film, boasting a grisly 30% approval rating, a stark difference from the doubled 60% viewership rating.

Like many long-running franchises, Pirates of the Caribbean became a series made for fans rather than critics, leading to a common disparity between the two groups with each new feature release. Fans obviously found Depp’s performance just as charming as in his previous four films, earning the film a generally fresh rating among audiences despite its low critical score.

The Greatest Showman (2017)

Available on Disney+

The greatest showman is one of the biggest disparities among critics and fans in recent history. The Hugh Jackman-directed musical was almost universally slammed by critics, but has become a national phenomenon. Rotten Tomatoes sums up this divide with a 30-point difference between critic and viewership scores, with the former offering a meager 56% approval rating, as opposed to an 86% fan score.

The greatest showman lacked many qualities that tend to appeal to critics, explaining its lack of success with film critics at the time of its release. Its soundtrack, however, made up for the film’s many flaws, creating a sensation that would last well beyond its theatrical release.

Passengers (2016)

Available to rent on Apple TV

Passengers was a highly anticipated film when it was released, thanks in particular to the notoriety of its two stars, Chris Pratt and Jennifer Lawrence. However, critics panned the film upon release, with Rotten Tomatoes offering a 30% score. Audiences, on the other hand, were easier on the film, garnering a 63% approval rating, 33 percentage points higher than critics.

Passengers probably didn’t land with critics due to its deeply flawed story that doesn’t justify the actions Chris Pratt’s character takes in the film’s first act. However, the ensuing story between Pratt and Lawrence proves entertaining enough to appease fans of the two immensely popular actors, explaining the higher viewership rating.

Captain Marvel (2019)

Available on Disney+

Coming just before the massive conclusion of the MCU’s Infinity Saga, Captain Marvel introduced the world to Brie Larson’s eponymous superhero, a character who is being set to lead the MCU in the future. While the film’s score on Rotten Tomatoes was consistent with other MCU installments, earning a 79% freshness rating, audiences were less satisfied, offering only a 45% approval rating.

Whereas Captain Marvel fits perfectly into the MCU, it lacks some of the charm that has made other films in the universe a success. Despite a strong performance from Larson and plenty of teasing for the future of the MCU, the film’s release directly between two big avengers the crossovers associated with the pushback from a small but vocal contingent of sexist viewers probably didn’t help boost its viewership score.

Batman V. Superman: Dawn of Justice (2016)

Available on HBO Max

Batman vs. Superman: Dawn of Justice was supposed to kick off the DCEU and lead to an upcoming Justice League crossover. However, the film was widely panned by critics on Rotten Tomatoes after its release, earning an abysmal 29% approval rating. However, fans were much more forgiving with the film, with the viewership score reaching 63%, which is a disparity of 34 points.

dawn of justice proved remarkably divisive in the months following its release, with many fans praising Zack Snyder’s artistic vision. However, many of the film’s critics point out that Snyder’s admittedly interesting take on DC’s heroes also tends to overpower their best qualities. In the end, it wasn’t long before the movie’s version of Superman and Batman left the franchise, leaving the DCEU in desperate need of leadership.

The Lion King (2019)

Available on Disney+

In 2019, The Lion King continued Disney’s controversial trend of rebooting its classic live-action animated films. Critics disliked Jon Favreau’s reimagining of the original film, giving the reboot a 52% on Rotten Tomatoes. Audiences, on the other hand, seemed to approve of the film, giving it an 88% approval rating and making the reboot one of the highest-grossing films of all time.

The 36-point disparity between critics and audiences on this movie speaks to the biggest divide between Disney fans over whether or not Disney should continue to remake its hit live-action films. The Lion King continued that ongoing discussion, though its high box office numbers seem to indicate that live-action reboots are here to stay.

Aladdin (2019)

Available on Disney+

The 2019 reboot of Aladdin proved as controversial as many of Disney’s live-action remakes, with critics panning the film. Critics at Rotten Tomatoes gave the reboot a 57% rating, but were outdone by fans, who rated the film 47 percentage points higher, with a solid score of 94%.

Critics continue to be ambivalent toward Disney’s live-action remakes, but Aladdin proved that audiences are still willing to enjoy rebooted classics as long as they remain sufficiently faithful to the source material. AladdinThe success of even led to a greenlit sequel, though the film’s status remains in limbo after Genie actor Will Smith’s recent PR nightmare.

Star Wars: The Last Jedi (2017)

Available on Disney+

Star Wars: The Last Jedi is one of the most controversial box office behemoths of all time. Despite its enormous financial success, few viewers can agree on the eighth installment of the Skywalker saga. Rotten Tomatoes features a wide disparity between critics and fans, with the former group praising the film after a 91% rating and the latter offering a meager 42% approval consensus.

This massive gap, filled by a whopping 49 percentage point gap, compounded a disappointing trend in the star wars fanbase which has resulted in nasty interactions and toxicity among some fans who disagree. Whereas The Last Jedi isn’t the best or worst film in the franchise, whatever many avid viewers may believe, it’s certainly the most talked about entry in the long-running saga.

NEXT: The 13 Movies Of The 2010s With 0% On Rotten Tomatoes


Comments are closed.